The love–hate relationship every Florida homeowner understands.

Florida and pools go hand-in-hand almost like sunshine and flip-flops.
They’re part of the lifestyle, the fantasy, and the postcard image people imagine when they think about moving to the Sunshine State. Summer fun, barbecues by the water, family gatherings, kids splashing while someone works the grill. For many, a pool is the dream.

But the reality? Owning a pool in Florida is both a gift and a curse.

From cooling off in our extreme heat to questioning the responsibility of maintenance, insurance, liability, and landlord obligations… Florida pools invite both joy and headaches.

‍
Here’s the truth about pools, whether you’re a homeowner, a buyer, or a landlord.

The Gift: Why Florida Pools Are So Attractive

1. Year-Round Enjoyment

Florida “winter” is basically a soft breeze and a hoodie. On some days, it's warm enough for a quick dip or a relaxing soak. Pools are usable nearly 10–12 months a year — especially in Central Florida where sunny days are the norm.

2. A Built-In Entertainment Zone

Holiday parties, birthday gatherings, family reunions, the pool becomes the central hub of the home.
In Florida, outdoor living is lifestyle, and a pool gives:

• A space for cooking out
• A backdrop for socializing
• A water escape for kids and teens
• A default weekend plan
• A beautiful visual from the inside

3. Resale Appeal: When Buyers Actually Want a Pool

Some buyers are specifically searching for a pool. In Florida, especially in suburbs like Oviedo, Winter Springs, Orlando, Apopka, and Altamonte, a well-maintained pool can help your home stand out.

For the right buyer, a pool isn’t just an amenity, it’s a lifestyle upgrade.

The Curse: What Pool Owners Don’t Talk About Enough

1. Maintenance: It’s Not Set-It-and-Forget-It

Pools require:

• Weekly chemical balancing
• Filtering
• Skimming
• Pump maintenance
• Tile and surface care
• Leak detection

And yes… it costs more than people think, especially if you hire a professional.

2. Insurance & Liability Risks

In Florida, pools mean:

• Higher homeowners insurance
• Safety requirements (screens, alarms, gates)
• Potential injury claims
• Extra scrutiny during underwriting

If you’re a landlord, multiply this by two.

3. For Landlords: Pools Can Be a Nightmare — or a Gold Mine

Tenants love the idea of a pool until:

• Something breaks
• Algae forms
• It needs resurfacing
• A storm dumps branches into it

Landlords must:

• Add a pool addendum
• Decide who handles maintenance
• Build pool service into rent
• Add strict safety rules
• Get proper insurance

A pool can increase rent if you manage it correctly.

4. Some Buyers Immediately See “Work, Cost, and Responsibility”

Not everyone wants:

• The liability
• The upkeep
• The ongoing expense
• The safety concerns (kids, pets)

And those objections can collapse a deal instantly.

What This Means for Home Buyers

If you're buying a home with a pool, here’s what to look for:

✔️ Age of the pool and equipment

Older pumps and older finishes = higher near-term expenses.

✔️ Surface condition (pebble, marcite, quartz)

Look for cracking, discoloration, or rough texture.

✔️ Enclosure condition

Screens break often during storms. Replacements add up.

✔️ Pump + filter health

A 15-year-old pump is a ticking expense.

✔️ Safety features

Florida requires alarms, fences, or enclosures—usually all three.

✔️ Drain compliance

Very important for older pools; check for anti-entrapment covers.

✔️ Professional inspection

Always hire a pool-specific inspector in addition to a general inspector.

Buying a house with a pool should be a lifestyle choice — not an emotional impulse.

Creative Ways to Reframe an “Unwanted” Pool When Selling

Sometimes a pool scares buyers away.
But there are surprising and creative ways to flip the narrative:

1. Convert it into a “Sunken Patio Oasis”

Drain, fill the bottom with gravel, cap the top, and turn it into:

• A firepit lounge
• An outdoor movie area
• A garden terrace
• A modern conversation pit

This is trendy, unexpected, and can make the home feel custom.

2. Securely Cover the Pool for a “Decked Outdoor Living Space”

A high-quality engineered deck can:

• Give you a new entertaining area
• Reduce maintenance
• Allow future owners to restore the pool
• Attract buyers who want low-maintenance outdoor living

3. Market it as a “Pool-Optional Home”

Some buyers love the idea of eventually restoring it.
This gives them flexibility.

4. Sell the Pool as a Resale Asset

Yes pools increase:

• Airbnb appeal
• Rental performance
• Buyer eyes on listings
• Visual curb appeal

It’s about presentation and condition.

Pool Seller Dos & Don’ts

DO:

✔️ Get the pool professionally cleaned before listing
✔️ Fix broken screens
✔️ Repair the pump if it’s struggling
✔️ Show the pool lit at night (HUGE impact)
✔️ Stage the outdoor area like a resort

DON’T:

❌ Let algae show
❌ Leave cracks visible
❌ Skip safety disclosures
❌ Let the waterline get grimy
❌ Hide maintenance history

Florida Winter: Where the Pool Never Closes

Florida’s "winter" is famous for something magical:

While other states are shoveling snow…
we’re grilling by the pool.

Holiday gatherings can spill outdoors.
Kids can swim on Christmas Day.
Family can relax under warm December sunshine.

A pool becomes the centerpiece of the holiday memories many families cherish in Florida.

A Pool Is a Lifestyle Choice, Not Just a Feature

If you love outdoor living, warm winters, holiday barbecues, and year-round sunshine — a pool can be one of the best features of your home.

But if you’re a low-maintenance lifestyle person or a landlord managing tenants, it can feel like more work than reward.

The key is knowing yourself and understanding the true commitment.

Disclaimer

This blog is for educational purposes only.
I am not an attorney.
For legal advice regarding pool regulations, landlord responsibilities, or liability, consult a licensed Florida attorney or qualified professional.

‍

Dionne Aiken
‍REALTOR® | Coldwell Banker Realty
📍 Central Florida
‍legacymoves.com